Electric vehicles (EVs) have been touted as the future of transportation, offering a cleaner and more sustainable alternative to traditional petrol cars. But are they really cheaper to run in the long run? In this blog post, we’re going to explore the cost comparison between an EV and a petrol car on a 200-mile journey.
To conduct this test, we have two sets of cars – a fully electric BMW I4 and a petrol-powered BMW M440i Grand Coupe. Both cars are similar in terms of performance and features, with the main difference being the power source. We start our journey from Cbum Services on the M25 south of London, heading towards Leeds, which is approximately 200 miles away.
The BMW I4 is equipped with a powerful battery with a claimed WLTP range of around 300 miles. However, the efficiency of electric cars at higher speeds, especially on the motorway, can impact the actual range. On the other hand, the BMW M440i has a 3-liter straight-six petrol engine, which is expected to average around 35 MPG.
As we navigate through the traffic and unexpected detours, we monitor the fuel consumption and battery usage of both cars. The BMW I4 shows impressive efficiency but struggles to maintain range on the motorway, while the BMW M440i performs well within its expected MPG range.
After a close call with running out of battery, we finally reach the ionity charger in Leeds to refuel the BMW I4. The cost of charging the electric car turns out to be higher than filling up the petrol car, primarily due to the expensive charging rates at public stations.
On the return journey, we switch to a petrol-powered Peugeot 208 and its electric counterpart, the e208. The e208, despite being a good electric car, falls short in terms of range compared to the petrol version, requiring multiple charging stops to complete the journey.
In the end, we compare the total costs of running the electric and petrol cars on the 200-mile journey. While the initial assumption that EVs are significantly cheaper to run is challenged by the test results, it’s important to consider factors such as charging infrastructure, electricity prices, and home charging capabilities.
Ultimately, the cost-effectiveness of electric cars depends on individual circumstances and usage patterns. For those who have access to affordable home charging options, EVs can offer significant savings in the long term. However, for those who rely on public charging stations, the cost comparison may not be as favorable.
As the automotive industry continues to evolve towards electrification, it’s crucial for consumers to weigh the pros and cons of electric vehicles in terms of both environmental impact and financial considerations. To stay informed about the latest developments in electric cars and petrol cars, visit our website for in-depth reviews and comparisons.
In conclusion, the journey to determine the cost of running an EV versus a petrol car may have its challenges, but it sheds light on the evolving landscape of transportation and the choices we have to make for a sustainable future.
